GoodSense Tussin DM Cough and Chest Congestion , 8 Fluid Ounce [amazon.com]

Switch to "One-time Purchase"
Change quantity to 4
Switch back to "Subscribe & Save"
Review Subscription

Checkout should look like this:

Items (4): $13.44
Shipping & handling: $0.00
Promotion Applied: -$5.00
Subscribe & Save: -$2.02
Total before tax: $6.42

Part of the Buy 4, Save $5 promo found here [amazon.com].